"The Insurance Industry Made $169 Billion Last Year. Your Adjuster Says There's 'No Money' for Your Case."
Record Insurance Profits, Record Lowball Offers

In 2022, the auto insurance industry begged for relief. They were drowning in claims, they said. Losing $21 billion a year. Rate hikes were the only thing standing between them and ruin.
Two years later, in 2024, the same industry booked $169 billion in profit — a 333% swing in 24 months. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners said it plainly in writing: the windfall was “made possible largely due to sizeable rate increases.”
Translation: they jacked up your premium, paid out roughly the same in claims, and pocketed the difference.
South Carolina drivers footed the bill.
Average full-coverage premiums in SC jumped 29% in a single year between 2023 and 2024. The South Carolina Department of Insurance approved one hike after another:
• State Farm — +10.3%
• Farm Bureau — +11.2%
• Berkley — +19.6%
• Old Dominion — +22.2%
Where did the money go?
Not to claims. Not to faster settlements. Try here:
• Allstate CEO Tom Wilson took home $26.1 million in 2024 — a 62% raise.
• Progressive’s CEO made up to $48.99 million counting stock appreciation.
• Travelers’ CEO made $23.1 million — 191 times his median employee’s pay.
• Allstate authorized a new $1.5 billion stock buyback.
• Progressive paid out roughly $8 billion in variable dividends to shareholders in 2025 and 2026.
What the industry’s own data says about lawyers.
The Insurance Research Council — funded by the carriers themselves — admits the truth: injured people who hire a lawyer recover roughly 3.5 times more than people who try to handle the claim alone. Eighty-five percent of all bodily-injury settlement dollars go to represented claimants.
Insurance companies know exactly what an unrepresented person is worth to them. Less.
So when the adjuster calls…
…friendly, fast, and pressuring you to sign — remember who they actually work for. It is not you. The first offer is not your case’s value.
It’s their starting bid.
If you’ve been hurt in a wreck anywhere in the Upstate, get someone in your corner before you sign anything, give a recorded statement, or accept a check.
Injured? NO way. Call Dunaway.
Free consultation. No fee unless we recover for you.
(864) 224-1144 www.dunawayfirm.com
Dunaway Law Firm, LLC — Anderson, South Carolina
Personal injury law for the Upstate.
Thomas W. Dunaway, IV — SC Bar No. 100807
This article is for general informational purposes and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Statistics cited are drawn from publicly reported industry filings, NAIC data, and SC Department of Insurance rate-filing records.











