Estate Settles Electrocution For $3.25M

Heath Hamacher • May 17, 2018

A mother who watched her teenaged daughter electrocuted by a fallen power line has settled her wrongful death lawsuit for $3.25 million, her attorneys report.

Ann Donald, the mother of 16-year-old Emily Rose Donald, sued Blue Ridge Electric Cooperative after Emily was killed after stepping outside her Liberty home on Jan. 2, 2014.

A Blue Ridge spokesman said the 7,200-volt power line fell after a squirrel touched the top of the pole, causing it to smolder for several hours before breaking.

Emily reportedly walked outside after seeing the fire in her front yard, and the wire made contact with her thigh.

One of the plaintiffs’ attorneys, Thomas “Field” Dunaway IV of Anderson, said that his firm sued BREC for wrongful death, survival action, conscious pain and suffering, and bystander liability because Ann Donald “watched the whole ordeal from a few feet away and could do nothing to save her daughter.”

Dunaway said that after one failed attempt at mediation, all parties sought out Tom Wills of Charleston, whose “expertise” led to the settlement.

“After 13 hours of back and forth between all parties, we finally agreed to settle the case for $3.25 million on Dec. 5, 2016,” Dunaway said. “This case was fought extremely hard by both sides and got very intense and personal at times.”

SETTLEMENT REPORT – WRONGFUL DEATH

Amount: $3,250,000
Case name: Bruce Byrholdt, as Personal Representative of the Estate of Emily Rose Donald v. Blue Ridge Electric Cooperative, Inc.
Court: Anderson County Court of Common Pleas
Judge: R. Lawton McIntosh
Mediator: Tom Wills of Charleston
Case No.: 2014-CP- 04-02629
Date of settlement: Dec. 5, 2016
Attorneys for plaintiff: Tom W. Dunaway III and Thomas “Field” Dunaway IV of Dunaway Law Firm; Mike Mullinax of Mullinax Law Firm; and Bruce Byrholdt of The Byrholdt & Drawdy Law Firm, all in Anderson
Attorney for defendants: Pope Johnson of Johnson & Barnette in Columbia

By Field Dunaway • September 30, 2026
Injured in an assault in SC? The state's Crime Victim Compensation Fund may cover medical bills, counseling & lost wages. Learn who qualifies & how to apply.
By Field Dunaway • September 14, 2026
You slip on a wet floor at the grocery store. You trip over a broken step at a friend's house. A neighbor's dog bites your kid. The first thing most people hear afterward is some version of "well, that's just an accident." Sometimes it is. But South Carolina law puts real duties on the people who own and control property, and when they ignore those duties and someone gets hurt, that's not an accident. That's a premises liability claim. Here's how it works, whether the property belongs to a business or a private homeowner. The property owner's duty depends on why you were there: South Carolina sorts visitors into three categories, and the owner's obligation changes with each one. Invitees are people on the property for the owner's benefit, usually customers. If you're shopping at Walmart, eating at a restaurant on Main Street, or walking through a hotel lobby, you're an invitee. The owner owes you the highest duty: they have to keep the property reasonably safe, inspect for hazards, and fix or warn about dangers they knew or should have known about. That "should have known" language matters. A store can't just say "nobody told us about the spill." Licensees are social guests, people there with permission but for their own purposes. That's you at your buddy's cookout or your in-laws' house for Thanksgiving. A homeowner owes a licensee a duty to warn about hidden dangers the homeowner actually knows about. If they know the back deck railing is loose and don't say anything, they've got a problem. If they had no idea, the analysis gets harder. Trespassers get the least protection. An owner generally only has to avoid willful or wanton harm to an adult trespasser. Children are a different story. Under what courts call the attractive nuisance doctrine, an owner who keeps something a child is likely to wander toward (a pool, an old refrigerator, construction equipment) can be liable even if the child had no permission to be there. Figuring out which category applies is the first thing we do on every premises case, because it sets the standard the owner is held to. What this means for businesses: Businesses in Upstate South Carolina deal with the public all day, which means they deal with invitees all day. The most common claims we see against commercial property owners involve slip and falls from spills, freshly mopped floors with no warning signs, or leaks in the produce section; parking lot hazards like potholes, poor lighting, and broken curbs; falling merchandise from overstocked shelves; stairs and walkways with broken handrails or uneven surfaces; and negligent security in places like apartment complexes, bars, and parking decks where the owner knew about prior crime and did nothing. The fight in most of these cases is about notice. To win a slip and fall in South Carolina, you generally have to show the business either created the hazard, knew about it, or that it existed long enough that a reasonable business should have found it. That's why we send preservation letters fast. Surveillance footage, incident reports, and sweep logs tend to disappear if nobody asks for them. What this means for homeowners: Homeowners are surprised to learn they can be sued for a guest's injury. But in practice, the claim is usually made against the homeowner's insurance policy, not against the homeowner personally. Most standard homeowner's policies carry liability coverage, often $100,000 to $300,000, precisely for this situation. Common homeowner premises claims include dog bites, falls on stairs, decks, or icy walkways, swimming pool injuries, and injuries from unmaintained structures like rotted porches or collapsing sheds. Dog bites deserve their own mention. South Carolina has one of the more favorable dog bite laws in the country for injured people. Under S.C. Code § 47-3-110, a dog owner is strictly liable when their dog bites or attacks someone who is in a public place or lawfully on private property. You don't have to prove the dog was vicious before, and you don't have to prove the owner was careless. The main defense is that the injured person provoked the dog or was trespassing. When the government owns the property: Falls at the courthouse, on a county sidewalk, or in a public park fall under the South Carolina Tort Claims Act. These cases have shorter deadlines and damage caps, and the procedure is unforgiving. If you were hurt on public property, do not wait to talk to a lawyer. The clock on these cases runs faster than people think. "But I should have been watching where I was going": Insurance adjusters love this line. South Carolina uses a modified comparative negligence rule: your recovery is reduced by your share of fault, and you're barred from recovering only if you're 51% or more at fault. Being partly responsible does not kill your case. It's a negotiation point, and the adjuster is going to try to inflate it. Don't give a recorded statement before you've talked to someone who represents you. What to do if you've been injured on someone's property: Get medical care first. Then, if you can, take photos of the hazard before it gets cleaned up or fixed. Report the incident to the owner or manager and ask for a copy of any incident report. Get names and phone numbers of anyone who saw what happened. Keep the shoes and clothes you were wearing. And don't sign anything or accept a quick payment from an insurance company until you understand what your case is worth. In South Carolina, you generally have three years from the date of injury to file a premises liability lawsuit. Three years sounds like a long time. It isn't, especially when evidence disappears within days. Talk to a premises liability lawyer in Anderson: Dunaway Law Firm has handled premises liability cases across Anderson County and the Upstate, from slip and falls at big-box retailers to dog bites in residential neighborhoods. We know the notice arguments, we know the insurance carriers, and we know how to move fast on preserving evidence. If you were hurt on someone else's property, call us for a free consultation. There's no fee unless we win . Call 864-224-1144 They have insurance. You have us!
Traffic during commuting hours on a interstate.
By Ashlee Edwards Aughtry • July 8, 2026
New 2024 data reveals the deadliest hour, day, and months to drive — plus South Carolina crash trends and what they mean for injured victims and their families.
The Supreme Court will hear a case testing caregiver accountability for ignoring medical needs.
By Ashlee Edwards Aughtry • June 25, 2026
The Supreme Court will hear a case testing caregivers accountability for ignoring medical needs, with implications for medical-malpractice & nursing-home patients.
By Field Dunaway • June 15, 2026
Why a Smaller Firm Can Get You a Bigger Check
By Field Dunaway • May 8, 2026
Call Dunaway Law Firm, LLC - It's FREE
By Field Dunaway • April 27, 2026
Record Insurance Profits, Record Lowball Offers 
By Field Dunaway • April 24, 2026
Suspect nursing home abuse? Avoid costly mistakes that can hurt your case. Learn what to do before it’s too late.
By Field Dunaway • April 13, 2026
How to recognize nursing home neglect and hold them accountable under S.C. law
February 25, 2026
Injured by a defective product? Learn your rights and when you may have a case. Speak with a product liability lawyer today.